Guide · Businesses · 3 min read · Updated 17 November 2026
Solid vs Perforated Shutters vs Security Grilles: Which to Choose?
Short answer
Solid roller shutters give the most physical protection and privacy but often face planning resistance on high streets. Perforated or punched shutters balance security with visibility of displays and are more widely accepted. Internal grilles and collapsible gates protect the glass less but keep the front looking open. The right choice depends on your risk, stock value, location and insurer's requirements.
The main options compared
Shop security is a balance between keeping intruders out, keeping the street attractive and meeting planning and insurance requirements. No single product suits every shop. A mobile phone shop on a busy parade faces different risks from a café in a market town, and the right protection reflects that. The table sets out how the main options compare, using typical fitted prices for a standard single shop front.
| Option | Guide price | Visibility when closed | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solid electric roller shutter | £1,500–£3,500 | None | High-value stock, rear and service doors |
| Perforated or punched shutter | £1,800–£4,000 | Partial, displays visible | High streets, conservation-sensitive areas |
| Collapsible security gate | £500–£1,400 per opening | Good | Doorways, internal lines of defence |
| Internal grille behind glass | Priced to size | Good | Listed buildings and strict planning areas |
Solid roller shutters
Solid shutters are made of interlocking steel or aluminium laths with no openings. When closed, they cover the whole frontage, protecting the glass from impact and hiding stock completely. They are the default choice for rear doors, loading bays and businesses with high-value goods. Double-walled insulated laths add rigidity and some thermal benefit where the shutter doubles as a door.
The downsides are mostly visual. Solid shutters create a blank, often graffiti-prone frontage after hours, and many councils resist them on shopping streets. They also hide window displays, which removes evening advertising. If you choose one for the front of a shop, expect planning to scrutinise it closely.
Perforated and punched shutters
Perforated shutters have small holes punched through the laths, while punched or vision shutters have larger slotted openings. Both let light from inside spill out and allow passers-by to see displays, which keeps the street feeling active and supports late window shopping. Councils are generally more comfortable with this type, and polycarbonate inserts can be added to vision laths to stop rubbish and weather getting through.
Security is still good, because the curtain remains a continuous steel or aluminium barrier with strong guides and bottom locking. The trade-off is that the glass behind is partly visible and exposed to small objects, so it should be laminated.
- Keeps window displays visible after closing
- Generally more acceptable to planning officers
- Still a physical barrier against ram-raids and smash-and-grab
- Light from inside helps natural surveillance of the street
- Costs slightly more than an equivalent solid shutter
Security grilles and collapsible gates
Collapsible gates are lattice steel gates that fold to the side of an opening. They are quick to operate, need no box above the opening and are often used on doorways, recessed entrances and inside shops to protect a counter or stockroom. Fixed or removable grilles behind the glass offer a lighter, open look, which is why they are common on listed buildings where external shutters would not be approved.
Because grilles and gates sit behind or within the frontage, the glass itself is not protected from being smashed. They stop people climbing in and grabbing stock, but a broken window still needs replacing. Many shops combine laminated glazing with an internal grille to get a good balance.
Insurance and security ratings
Before choosing, speak to your insurer. Some policies set minimum requirements for physical security on certain trades or stock values, and a few ask for products certified to a recognised security standard, such as LPS 1175, which rates resistance to forced entry. If your insurer has requirements, get them in writing and pass them to the installer so the specification matches.
Locking matters as much as the curtain. Look for strong bottom-rail locking, robust guides with wind locks or anti-lift features, and a motor with a safety brake. Keyed or fob switches should be mounted where they cannot be easily tampered with.
Manual or electric operation
Most shop shutters are now electric, with a tubular motor inside the barrel and a key switch, fob or remote. Electric operation makes opening and closing quick and consistent, reduces wear from uneven manual lifting and lets staff secure the shop without strain at the end of the day. It also makes larger shutters practical, since a wide steel curtain is heavy to lift by hand.
Manual shutters still have a place on small openings that are rarely used, such as a side window or a store cupboard, and collapsible gates are always manual. If you choose electric, ask about a manual override for power cuts and where the switch will be mounted. A switch inside the shop protects it from tampering, but then you need another secure way in, so many shops use an external key switch in a tamper-resistant housing.
Making the decision
Start by listing what you are protecting against: casual vandalism, smash-and-grab, ram-raids or break-ins through the back. Then check your planning constraints and insurer's requirements. For most high-street shops, a perforated electric shutter or laminated glazing with an internal grille offers the best mix of security, appearance and approval prospects. For rear doors and service areas, solid shutters remain the practical choice. An installer who surveys the premises can recommend combinations that fit your budget and risk.
Questions people also ask
Are perforated shutters as secure as solid shutters?
They are slightly less resistant to determined attack in some designs, because the perforations remove some material, but they still form a strong steel or aluminium barrier with the same guides and locking. For most shops the difference is small, and perforated shutters are more likely to get planning approval on a high street.
Can I fit a roller shutter inside my shop window?
Yes. Internal shutters and grilles can be fitted behind the glass, with the box concealed above a ceiling or behind a pelmet. They are often preferred by planners and are common on listed buildings, though listed building consent may still be needed. The glass remains exposed, so laminated glazing is recommended.
Do I need an insulated roller shutter?
Insulated laths are worthwhile when the shutter acts as the main door to a warehouse, workshop or storeroom that is heated or used as a working space. For a shutter that only covers a glazed shop front at night, insulation offers little benefit, and standard solid or perforated laths are usually more cost-effective.
Written and checked by the Shop Fronts and Shutters team. Read our editorial policy.
More guides
How Much Does a Shop Front or Roller Shutter Cost in the UK?
A typical aluminium shop front with an entrance door and laminated glass costs £3,500–£9,000 in the UK. Traditional timber shop fronts start from…
Do You Need Planning Permission for a Shop Front or Shutter?
In most cases, yes. Replacing or altering a shop front usually needs planning permission because it materially affects the appearance of the…
Roller Shutter Repair and Maintenance: A Guide for Shop Owners
Most roller shutter breakdowns come from worn motors, damaged laths, misaligned guides, faulty switches or broken springs on manual shutters. Owners…
Replacing a Shop Front: What Happens, Step by Step
Replacing a shop front starts with a survey and design, followed by any planning, listed building or landlord consents. The front is then made to…
Get a free shop fronts and shutters quote
Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a clear price.
Request a quote